Patent coverage – technical and geographic
Patent coverage (technical) – How much of a change avoids infringement?
The wording of the claims is critical. Each claim is a single sentence that can be thought of as a list of features. Generally speaking, to infringe a patent claim, each and every feature of the claim must be taken.
Example patent claim
A plumbing fitting including:
- an inlet conduit;
- a first outlet conduit;
- a second outlet conduit;
- a valve for closing the first outlet conduit; and
- a solenoid valve for closing the second outlet conduit.
Plumbing fittings which do not include a solenoid valve for closing the second conduit are not covered by this claim. Infringement could be avoided by substituting another type of valve for the solenoid valve.
On the other hand:
- the claim simply specifies ‘a valve for closing the first outlet conduit’ – a plumbing fitting including any type of valve for closing the first outlet conduit is covered; and
- the claim is silent on the inlet conduit having a valve, so the claim covers plumbing fittings with or without a valve on the inlet conduit.
A patent will typically include multiple claims of differing scope. To successfully enforce a patent, only one claim need be valid and infringed.
The approach to claim interpretation varies from country to country. In Australia, claim wording must be interpreted from the point of view of an individual familiar with the field of technology and given its plain and ordinary meaning in the context of the patent specification read as whole. Some countries, most notably the US, have rules which vary the scope of coverage relative to the plain meaning of the claim wording.
Patent coverage (geographic)
As a general rule, patents are granted separately on a country-by-country basis, although:
- Europe will soon implement a Unitary Patent System which provides a single patent covering multiple countries;
- international patent application and European patent applications provide single application processes that can lead to patent rights in multiple countries;
- an international convention (the Paris convention) has long allowed a single national patent application to serve as a starting point for applying for patent rights internationally.
Does an Australian patent cover New Zealand?
No, although an Australian patent application is often a good first step towards patents in both countries. There are usually efficiencies when applying for protection in both countries.
Do international patents apply in Australia?
International patents applications apply in Australia, but there is no such thing as international patent. International patent applications only last until about 31 months after the first patent application. The applicant must take action to ‘enter the national phase’ in Australia by then or the international patent application will no longer apply in Australia.